10 stars
9 stars
8 stars
7 stars
6 stars
5 stars
4 stars
3 stars
2 stars
1 star
Overview
Few experiences compare to joining an active fan community as they test a fresh nonlinear title in genres such as Metroidvania and Soulslike. In Hollow Knight: Silksong, players report outcomes that differ radically—even within just a few hours of play. Some enthusiasts choose to spend their time engaging in combat with relentless bosses or brave lengthy sequences filled with demanding platform segments, while others follow entirely different paths, seeking hidden areas and subtle details that even a veteran reviewer might easily overlook. This game departs in several important ways from its predecessor, boasting a notably larger map and considerably more content in the base game.
Varied Player Experiences
Many in the community have expressed a clear perspective regarding certain aspects of Hollow Knight: Silksong. A considerable number of players grumble about receiving heavy blows—often amounting to the loss of two damage masks—from most enemy encounters. A shared grievance centers around some of the more repetitive platform segments and extended boss battles. Specific encounters, such as those against Hunter’s March and Savage Beastfly, have left many players with a sense of fatigue. The consensus shared among reviewers is that the in-game economy, centered on rosary beads, feels particularly limiting. In many sessions played in Pharloom, the currency seems to vanish far too rapidly, leaving players frequently short and forced to rethink their strategy.
The Economy of Rosary Beads
Rosary beads in this title emerge as one of the most polarizing aspects of the gameplay. From the outset, it becomes apparent that accumulating a significant reserve of these beads is neither a gentle nor slow process. Bosses throughout the game do not contribute to rosary collection at all, and even the lesser foes only release very small amounts when defeated. It is not uncommon to encounter beads placed in the environment—whether dangling from strings that require a careful cut or hidden away in sparse chests. These beads appear intermittently and often require long treks across the game world to secure them, especially in the early hours of play. Often, players might find themselves staring at a meager collection while other in-game demands compel them to spend what they have accumulated.
There is a notable segment in the Choral Chambers—specifically, the stretch between the Cogwork Dancers and Songclave with a scattering of Grand Reeds—that offers a chance to farm these beads at a reasonable rate. Still, the game rarely rewards a relaxed pace, continuously challenging the player to balance resource gathering against an onslaught of potential threats. Even those prepared to persevere in search of an abundant bead harvest must contend with an economy that forces nearly every decision to revolve around careful spending. Each encounter becomes a moment of tension because a misstep or unexpected fall might mean losing a precious amount of beads that took considerable effort to acquire.
Converting and Protecting Your Resources
A singular mechanic that some players find useful is the ability to convert forfeitable rosaries into a different inventory item: a rosary string. This special item is immune to loss on death, allowing players to safeguard their hard-earned reserves. The catch is steep, however. Transforming a collection so that 60 beads are locked into safety demands spending 80 rosaries in total. For many, this conversion feels like a heavy taxation that discourages routine use. Balancing the potential benefits of a string against the high conversion rate has become a delicate decision for those who yearn to cautiously move deeper into the game without the constant dread of resource loss.
Encounters and the Cost of Death
Difficulty in Hollow Knight: Silksong is amplified not solely by the rigors of combat, but also by the many airborne adversaries lurking in the skies. Enemies such as Driznits, Reeds, Skarrwings, Squatcraws, and Winged Pilgrim Bellbearers are notorious for their unpredictable strikes. Repeated encounters with these foes have led many to become very familiar with the sting of defeat. On several occasions, players find themselves racing back along the perilous Sinner’s Road after a fatal encounter, forced to recover progress that can feel frustratingly lost.
An NPC in the vicinity offers a temporary reprieve in the form of Silkeaters. Consuming one of these items facilitates the retrieval of a cocoon—a safeguard after experiencing defeat in battle. Many players have taken to hoarding Silkeaters, especially when their rosary reserves reach 500 or more. The need to minimize the trips back to recover fallen progress has become a constant consideration, particularly in areas like Bellways and Ventricas, where disorientation might lead the player into unexpected hardship.
The Impact of In-Game Spending
Even for those who quickly master the combat and platforming demands of Silksong, financial strain remains a persistent issue. Choosing to purchase any piece of equipment or donating beads at a wishwall almost always leaves the player with a noticeably depleted supply. Virtually every item available from in-game vendors carries an exorbitant price tag. Simple keys, rare and difficult to obtain, alone are a heavy burden on the rosary economy. In Bone Bottom, a pair of these keys might set you back 500 rosaries, and in Songclave, that same pair demands 650 rosaries. The steep pricing forces every purchase to be weighed carefully; each expense chips away at reserves painstakingly collected through hours of exploration and combat.
For players inclined to experiment with various tools and upgrades, the challenge grows even more severe. Every additional investment in tools, modifications, or consumable enhancements further diminishes the modest pool of beads. Some areas of the game demand such a high rate of expenditure that even basic functions become a luxury. One particularly grueling section—the Underworks—proved to be a taxing foray for those who faced it without a single bead in reserve. A modest bench, available for a sum as low as 15 rosaries, becomes a critical purchase when funds are low, forcing a pause in the player’s forward momentum.
Preparing for Critical Regions
The design of Hollow Knight: Silksong leaves many players reconsidering their exploration habits—not only because of the risk of head-on battles, but also because of the constant anxiety over managing such a fragile currency. In many instances, the unavoidable loss of Silk and rosaries upon defeat means that every step is taken with heightened caution. The game’s mechanics compel players to weigh the immediate rewards of venturing into new areas against the potential setback of losing progress. In a genre where careful exploration is meant to be a core pleasure, the threat of a sudden drop in resources forces a cycle of hoarding and spending that can disrupt the natural pace of exploration.
This pressing concern has created a pattern: many find themselves trying to amass around 200 rosaries before making any significant purchase from a character like Bellhart. Yet it is almost inevitable that these carefully earned beads are quickly consumed by mandatory expenses, such as unlocking new passages, repairing essential checkpoints, or purchasing necessary upgrades. As each encounter and obstacle drains the available currency, the overall enjoyment of the game’s free-form exploration is diminished by the constant need to monitor spending.
A Question of Design Philosophy
There is an ongoing discussion among players regarding the intention behind the game’s harsh economic mechanics. Some argue that losing both Silk and rosaries upon death mirrors elements found in other challenging titles, particularly those in the Blasphemous series. In those games, a high level of difficulty comes without the added layer of losing significant in-game wealth that may have taken hours across numerous challenging biomes to accumulate. This comparison raises a critical question: does the penalty on death serve as a meaningful challenge, or does it overly restrict progress and access to additional content?
At present, many players feel that the system in Silksong carries an excessive penalty on failure. The thought that every untimely defeat not only resets strategic progress but also subtracts from hard-won resources diminishes the overall reward of carefully managing encounters. Despite the possibility that the later stages—hidden within Act 3—might introduce more efficient means to obtain rosaries, the early experience sets a tone of frustration. In these moments, the monetary loss overshadows the satisfaction of victory, prompting even experienced players to approach new areas with a pronounced sense of trepidation.
Balancing Risk and Reward
The careful design of resource allocation in Hollow Knight: Silksong creates a persistent sense of caution among players. Every move becomes a calculated risk; every new area or boss encounter represents the possibility of losing precious beads that are essential for upgrading equipment or purchasing necessary items from vendors. The balance between risk and reward is delicate. If a player pushes too far without adequate safeguards, the resulting setbacks can feel both disheartening and demoralizing.
This aspect of the game has ended up discouraging broad exploration. The constant worry over what might be lost can reduce the urge to push further into uncharted sections of the map. Many players find themselves engaged in an endless loop: saving up just enough rosaries—often around 200 units—for a specific purchase from a vendor like Bellhart, only to see that stash rapidly diminished as they contend with recurring obstacles such as vital passageways and restorative benches. This financial strain adds a layer of strategic complexity that some find enriching, while others feel it detracts from what might have otherwise been an immersive exploration experience.
Reflecting on the Experience
Even if one manages to master the combat and precise platforming challenges throughout the game, the persistent state of scarcity often leaves players feeling perpetually short of resources. The design of Silksong forces many to adopt a cautious play style, one where every encounter is scrutinized not only for its immediate challenge but also for its potential economic cost. It is a juggling act, attempting to balance the thrill of discovery and combat with the inevitable worry of overspending in a system that offers little leeway for error.
For those committed to experiencing the game without external guidance—eschewing any comprehensive walkthroughs in favor of a genuine, unassisted exploration—the consequences of a miscalculation are all the more personal. Every failed attempt, every unexpected defeat, is a reminder of how merciless the management of Silk and rosaries can be. With each setback, players are forced to reassess their strategy and determine whether to push forward with diminished resources or retreat in order to rebuild their reserves for the challenges ahead.
Release Information
Hollow Knight: Silksong is set to offer an engaging single-player campaign tailored for fans of intricate combat and precise platforming challenges. The game has undergone testing to confirm compatibility with the Steam Deck, promising a reliable experience on that platform as well. The upcoming title will be available on multiple systems, launching simultaneously on PC, Xbox Series X|S, PS5, Nintendo Switch, and Nintendo Switch 2. All platforms are slated for release on September 4, 2025.
In summary, Hollow Knight: Silksong presents players with a multifaceted experience that demands both technical skill and careful economic strategy. The game’s expansive map and content-rich environment offer countless opportunities for discovery, yet the persistent challenge of managing a fragile rosary bead economy tends to shape every decision. For those who appreciate a game that forces strategic caution—where every combat encounter and every platform sequence carries the weight of potential financial loss—the title represents a rigorous test of both reflexes and resource management. For others, the constant risk of losing essential funds may detract from the overall enjoyment, making the choice of how and when to engage with these challenges a critical part of the experience.
Whether you find satisfaction in overcoming these obstacles or feel hindered by the relentless pressure on your in-game finances, Hollow Knight: Silksong stands as a bold attempt to evolve the formula that captured so many hearts in its predecessor. As players navigate every challenge while guarding their carefully earned beads, the game continually demands that they commit to a play style where every move counts—and where the cost of failure is always a tangible, lingering presence.
With its simultaneous launch across several major platforms on September 4, 2025, fans of the genre will soon have the opportunity to experience this demanding title firsthand. The decisions you make, and the risks you take, will define your progress in this meticulously challenging world. Embrace the tension of each encounter and prepare to test your skills in a game that holds nothing back when it comes to the price of failure.